Independent - Experienced - Always On Your Side

At Eastway Insurance Agency, you’re more than a policy number! They’ve been family-owned and operated in Penfield for over 40 years, and Joe and Jeremy treat every customer like they’re friends or family. As an independent agency, they don’t work for the insurance company, they work for you. That means they’re free to explore every option, compare plans across providers, and find the solution that truly fits your needs.

Their primary goal? Saving you money – because chances are you’re paying too much for your insurance! Joe and Jeremy will go out of their way to find you savings, even if it means keeping your current policy. Because they are dedicated to always doing what’s in your best interest.

From Auto and Home Insurance to Life and Medicare-eligible Health plans, Joe and Jeremy take the time to explain your options clearly, answer every question, and go out of their way to make the process easy. They focus on people, not policies—doing what’s right and making people smile.

Let Eastway Insurance Agency show you how much you can save. Request a free, no-obligation quote below!

Call Today: (585) 586-2390

Contact Eastway Insurance Agency

Your Name(Required)

First Last

Your Email(Required)

Your Phone Number(Required)

Your Question for Eastway Insurance Agency(Required)

CAPTCHA

"Jeremy and Josef really care about their clients. I highly recommend them for all of your insurance needs. Medicare managed plans, auto and apt/home. They know ALL of the details! Give them a call!"

"Kudos to Joe at East way Insurance for doing a thorough job getting me the best price for my car insurance. He literally saved me over $600 per year. I highly recommend."

"Joe is great to work with and tries hard to save everyone money on any insurance needs. Always there to help! Highly recommend his firm to anyone trying to save some money and a great agent to work with."

"I switched from Geico after decades and got a better price and better coverage through Eastway. I highly recommend them for your insurance needs!"

"It was time to do some comparison for home and auto insurance - Saved about 25% with a change to a highly rated company. Easy change, very personable agents. 5 Stars!"

“I felt that I was given personal attention. Joe had my best interest as he scrutinized my insurance documents for ways to save money and still get the coverage I need.”